The Global Economic Governance (GEG) Africa programme is a policy research and stakeholder engagement programme to strengthen the influence of pro-poor African coalitions at global economic governance fora.
GEGAfrica

GEGAfrica

SAIIA, DNA Economics and Tutwa Consulting are extremely pleased to be starting a new project on Global Economic Governance and Africa, the second phase of a project SAIIA ran from 2012-2015. The project is hiring a researcher.

SAIIA, DNA Economics and Tutwa Consulting are extremely pleased to be starting a new project on Global Economic Governance and Africa, the second phase of the project SAIIA ran from 2012-2015.

A new project, coordinated by SAIIA, is exploring how multilateral trade negotiations can be revitalised to overcome both existing and emerging challenges.

On 31 March 2015, the South African Institute of International Affairs hosted a G-20 Study Group on 'Turkey and the G-20 Presidency: Implications for Africa.'

In July 2014, the BRICS grouping (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa), announced the creation of a new, US$100 billion New Development Bank to lend money to developing nations for investments. There is much speculation about the role the Bank might play, and the motivations of the BRICS members in establishing it.

The summit released a range of action plans that aim to coordinate the action of the G20 countries and partner organizations:

  1. The St Petersburg Action Plan
  2. The Workplan on Long-Term Investment Promotion
  3. The St Petersburg Development Outlook
  4. The G20 approach to Advancing Transparency in Regional Trade Agreements

 

Beyond the coordination of G20 activities, the declaration made extensive reference to international organisations and their work. These partner organisations include the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), the World Bank Group, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the International Labor Organization (ILO), the World Trade Organization (WTO), the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), and numerous others. Indeed, large parts of the declaration seem to build directly on the work by these organisations. This highlights the G20’s commitment to acting as coordinating body for the pre-existing array of International Organisations. However, it also points to the G20s weak institutional capacity to act independently, and raises questions as to whether the G20 guides or follows these international bodies – whether it is dog or tail.  

A list of selected G20 areas of cooperation and coordination are as follows:

  1. Working with the ILO, OECD and World Bank on unemployment best practices, with coordination undertaken by the G20 Task Force on Employment.
  2. Continuing and developing work completed by the World Bank Group and Regional Development Banks, on how best to optimise current supplies of development financing.
  3. Assisting the WTO in making progress at the Bali Ministerial Conference (MC9), while acknowledging the important monitoring of trade and investment data undertaken by the WTO, OECD, and UNCTAD.
  4. Supporting the Transparency in Trade Initiative (TNT) undertaken by the World Bank and the UNCTAD.
  5. Supporting the work of the OECD, WTO and UNCTAD on global value chains and calls to deliver a final report on the subject in the first half of 2014
  6. A joint project by the G20 and OECD on tax Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS), and endorsing the related Action Plan. This builds onissues also tackled under the auspices of the G8.
  7. Endorsing the OECD’s work on creating a global standard for the exchange of tax information between G20 countries, while urging all countries to sign the OECD’s Convention on Mutual Administration Assistance in Tax Matters.
  8. Highlighting recent work undertaken by the IMF and G20 on Regional Financial Arrangements (RFAs).
  9. Expressing support for the IMF and World Bank’s work on reviewing and updating Guidelines for Public Debt Management.
  10. Supporting the implementation of the IMF-World Bank Debt Sustainability Framework for Low-Income Countries
  11. Expressing support for the IMF and Bank for International Settlement’s continued work in developing indicators that reflect global liquidity conditions.
  12. Noting the work undertaken by various international organizations – including the IMF, World Bank, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development – to implement the G20 Action Plan on the Development of Local Currency Bond Markets (LCBMs)
  13. Commiting to contribute to a successful replenishment of the International Development Association and the African Development Fund.
  14. Expressing support on a range of financial reforms undertaken by bodies such as the Financial Stability Board, Board for International Settlements, Basel Committee on Banking supervision, IMF, International Organisation of Securities Commissions, International Accounting Standards Board, and the World Bank Group.
  15. Supporting work on financial inclusion undertaken by the Global Partnership for Financial Inclusion, and its related organisations.
  16. Expressing support for the UN’s work on the creation of a post-2015 development agenda.
  17. Committing to strengthen the Joint Organisations Data Initiative (JODI), and related work on transparency in energy markets undertaken by the International Energy Agency, International Energy Forum, and the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries.
  18. Continuing efforts to fight climate change under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Chance.
  19. Supporting the OECD’s work on corruption, including the launch of the Issues Paper on Anti-Corruption and Economic Growth, and urging ratification by all members of the UN Convention Against Corruption
Tuesday, 11 November 2014 15:58

St Petersburg, 2013 - Comprehensive Coverage

The declaration makes no specific mention of Africa, and includes limited mention of African organisations, with the exception of the African Development Bank and a broad reference to regional trade agreements. Despite this, the summit covered a wide range of issues, many of which are of vital importance to African concerns.

The St Petersburg Development Outlook perhaps best demonstrates this focus, and concerns itself with six areas of relevance to African countries:

  1. Food Security: Deepening activities focused on facilitating knowledge sharing and improving research on agricultural issues.
  2. Infrastructure: Assessing ongoing projects and providing new resources for practitioners, such as a public-private partnership sourcebook and a toolkit on urban mass transportation infrastructure.
  3. Financial Inclusion: Continued support for the Global Partnership for Financial Inclusion.
  4. Human Resource Development: Launch of a knowledge sharing platform.
  5. Inclusive Green Growth: Launch of a toolkit on green growth, and initiation of a G20 Dialogue Platform on Inclusive Green Investments.
  6. Domestic Resource Mobilisation: Continuing work through partner organizations on improving tax administration.

 

While the Development Outlook covers many issues of vital importance to Africa and developing countries in general, it should be noted that the Outlook is primarily a refining of pre-existing programmes, with new initiatives mainly taking the form of knowledge sharing. Few concrete, material commitments are contained within the Development Outlook, although such commitments may be possible in the ensuing work of related bodies.

More broadly, the Summit Declaration touches on many areas of importance to African states. Given the reliance on Africa on the state of the global economy, all issues discussed within the declaration are indirectly relevant to the continent, but six should be noted:

  1. Unemployment and underemployment, particularly amongst the youth.
  2. The risks associated with capital flows in response to the tapering of monetary stimulus in advanced economies.
  3. Addressing current account imbalances, and high trade deficits in many countries.
  4. Improving local climate for long-term investments, with an aim set for the Brisbane summit.
  5. Assisting least developed countries in applying the OECD tax information standard.
  6. Improving financial inclusion

 

Point 2 is perhaps worth special mention. The summit took place against the back-drop of currency instability in large emerging markets, such as South Africa and India, driven by concerns that a weakening of monetary stimulus in advanced economies, particularly the United States, could slow credit-driven growth in emerging markets. These concerns were acknowledged by the communiqué, and it was emphasised that monetary policy will continue to be focused on the domestic price stability and growth. However there was little practical effort made to address these concerns, barring a call to carefully communicate and calibrate monetary policy actions. While the tapering has since been delayed, a more comprehensive response to this issue was perhaps needed to alleviate developing country, and African, concerns.

Few major administrative actions were taken during the St Petersburg Summit. Some of the existing institutional arrangements, such as the G20 Task Force on Employment, had their mandate renewed for a further year, while others were modified slightly, for example with adjustments made to the operational practices of the Development Working Group, which is set to move to a more limited but focused agenda on a few key areas, and will seek to improve coordination, accountability and engagement in work between countries and international organisations. Finally, a joint meeting of Labour and Employment and Finance Ministers was held for the first time, as part of the employment creation agenda.

The declaration also made note of administrative changes in key partner organisations. The declaration welcomed the establishment of the Financial Stability Board as an independent legal entity, while urging continued reviews of the structure of its representation. The summit also called for continued efforts to reform the governance of the International Monetary Fund, particularly the ratification of the 2010 IMF Quota and Governance Reform, which should be addressed during the 2014 General Quota Review.

As with other accords, the declaration carefully and consistently notes that all actions are to be undertaken on the basis of willful cooperation and national action, thus demonstrating their respect for the principle of sovereignty. The declaration acknowledges that plans to promote employment must be tailored to each country’s specific constitutional and material circumstances, reinforcing the principle of non-discrimination. Finally, the declaration makes consistent note of the need for growth to be sustainable, and dedicates sections to green growth and investment, thus indicating an acknowledgement of the principle of Environmental Responsibility.

Tuesday, 11 November 2014 15:45

St Petersburg, 2013 - What is the Goal?

The summit declaration encompassed a broad range of goals that reflects the continuing evolution of the G20, from a crisis management body to a forum for cooperation to promote economic growth and development. While the declaration emphasized the need to build a durable recovery from the crisis, the core stated aim of the declaration was the broader mandate of achieving strong, sustainable, and balanced growth. The creation of jobs was given particular emphasis within this broad aim, as countries struggle to address rising unemployment, particularly amongst the youth.

These aims are set to be met by a number of more specific goals aimed at a broad range of issues. These include, but are not limited to: insuring long term finance for development and investment, promoting multilateral (and, to a lesser extent, plurilateral) trade, promoting tax transparency and fighting tax avoidance, strengthening the resilience of the international financial system, promoting environmentally sustainable growth, combatting corruption, and pursuing a collection of development goals collectively known as the St Petersburg Development Outlook. The Development Outlook includes areas of particular importance to developing countries, such as food security, infrastructure development, financial inclusion and human resource development.

The goals reinforce the commitment of the G20 to their stated aim of growth and development for all. While some aims, such as financial regulatory reform, are less pertinent to less developed African states, many of the goals fit those of the continent. The focus on unemployment is particularly important, since this is an issue of primary concern on the African continent. It is, however, uncertain to what extent this stated concern is driven by global, including African considerations, or by the weak employment figures in the G20 countries themselves, particularly Europe. The focus on unemployment may be driven more by incidental shared concerns, which makes it less likely that G20 efforts would place global, including African, interests above sovereign concerns. However, the St Petersburg Development Outlook is a strong Africa-focused addition to the summit goals, and focuses on important issues for the continent.

Page 2 of 5

Click the button below to receive email updates any time new GEG Africa material is posted. (Or click here to subscribe to the quarterly GEG Africa newsletter).

SUBSCRIBE